a lesson in history…

April 4, 2013

… … or in sex education (oh no!), if you will…

I have the shared the following story many times over in the past, with groups of school-going children, fellow ‘teachers’ and sometimes in the random corporate ‘training’ sessions that I have conducted – all lost in the swirling mists of the past.

Ah, the memories, sweet dreams are of course made of these!

Anyway, over to the story.


Many years ago – two children, siblings actually – one a 8 year old, the other 6 years of age were living in a distant suburb of Chennai – this suburb was quite close to the Meenambakkam Airport – and was more like a sparsely populated village in those days.

These children went to a happy municipality school close-by and were enjoying open spaces, clean air, safe environments… Oh those begone halcyon days of the past…

… And, on that day, these children were discussing some matter of earth shaking importance to them… A translated english transcript follows:

Presently 6 dawdles along and asks 8 in a semi hushed tone, with surreptitious glances, just in case…

6: Anna (‘elder brother’ in Tamil), is it possible for males to give birth to children?

8 is stunned and stumped – he thinks for a while, with the burdensome responsibility of an elder brother, who ought to know ‘things,’ weighing down heavily on him. He is given to devouring everything that has anything written on it and so is looked up in awe by 6; 8 is considered as a repository of all knowledge in the neighborhood. And so, 8 is already suffering from a very debilitating performance anxiety, because the question is very technical and he has had no direct experience in the domain. And so, 8 scans his brain, and aha, he has the answer staring at him. He is delighted.

8: Umm, yes Giri, I think it is possible for men to give birth to children.

6: Oh! (with obvious relief) I also guessed as much. It explains a lot of things. I too have seen so many pregnant men, but never thought that they too would have babies inside, instead of a huge stomach. I thought they ate too much. Heh!

8: Ummm. Ha ha!

6: But, but, how do you know that? Have you seen men delivering babies?

8: No. But I think it is possible.

6: How come then, we don’t hear of any man delivering babies?

8: Um.., I don’t know whether it is still possible, but am very sure that it has happened in the past. In those days, it must have been possible.

6: Really? So there are books about it??

8: Yes! I have read in our government ‘tamilnadu textbook society’ history books about these facts!

6: Oh really? Tell me, tell me more about that please, please! puhleeesse!!

8: Yeah. You see, in the Moghul history, this is what happened. Moghuls were the emperors of North India then. Babur started the dynasty. And then, Babur ‘got’ Humayun, Humayun ‘got’ Akbar, Akbar ‘got’ Jahangir and so on and so forth. They are all males you know – and still they ‘got’ their children. If you see their pictures you would understand…

6: Thanks Anna, (with a glowing face) you know like everything

8: (with obvious relief, but put on airs) ahem…


See, in those days 8 did know somewhat about the birds and bees – but not much. But, there were proofs to the contrary in the textbooks. Given the available information and weighing the rather public evidence, I suppose he came to a correct conclusion. What do you think?

I think it took many years for 8 to get out of the trauma of the discovery of ‘delivering’ men (as opposed to delivery boys). But finally he got his deliverance

At least I think so. I know that 8 year old rather intimately. It was actually yours truly.

But the state government texts and NCERT books are not to be blamed alone here… All the new fangled books for IGCSE to IB are full of these kinds of cognitive dissonances and uselessly lame ideas.  When are we ever going to learn from herstories, and itstories – and not merely from histories – if one looks at post-modern ways of thinking about things? bleh

… Anyway, this conversation happened some 40 years ago. The fact is that, the same state of affairs continues in the textbooks and in ‘education,’ is quite sad. But there is hope, as we will eventually arm our children with two questions (for any given context), that will open doors, provide pointers and make them good meta learners. These questions are very simple yet powerful – if asked, answered and then revised based on current understanding and emergent evidence; they are 1) Why and 2) Why not.

I am glad to say that in my schools, the children are encouraged to ask these kinds of questions, repeatedly, nay, incessantly… Hope the parents would pardon us.

JournalEntry: 5th October, 2008

5 Responses to “a lesson in history…”

  1. If you have spun your story around the common mistakes we Indians make in speaking or writing English or Tamil the same is true of even very expensive International Schools in Bangalore and Coimbatore. Occasionally I get the opportunity to read the circulars sent by the teachers and the school authorities of my grand children. I have observed silly grammar mistakes or inappropriate use of words.
    Even though my competency in English or for that matter in Tamil is not commendable I believe we did write better English or Tamil than the present day students and teachers in general. But the present day students, my sample consisting of my three school going grand children, read a lot and write a lot.

    சரி நம்ம விசயத்திற்கு வருவோம். Will you please point out the mistakes grammar or otherwise in the above piece of writing? Honestly I do not see any but there must be few.

  2. vishnuagni Says:

    Really funny and great to read!

  3. dagalti Says:

    Sir, I submit that 8 was way ahead of his time.
    The world is only now moving away from patriarchal oppressive notions and acknowledging biosociological flexibility with appropriate words like ‘birthing person’.

    8’s precociousness anticipates a life with much potential for guruhood.
    At the very least he may turn out to be a niche blogger catering to the cognoscente.

  4. SS Says:

    Oh wow! 8 has proved himself at such a young age(no wonder, impo). He has pinned down the the text book ‘twistorians’ and prophesied the emergence of sjw, woke, lgbtqiapk+++ warriors with his response, what a genius!

மேற்கண்ட பதிவு (அல்லது பின்னூட்டங்கள்) குறித்து (விருப்பமிருந்தால்) உரையாடலாமே...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s